Anthem Flap
So, all this panty knot-tying over weird harmonies?!?! I would LOVE to know what the venerable Joe J. Ringhofer (my history/harmony/analysis teacher, current Chief Examiner of theory at the dastardly RCM - which means the man KNOWS HIS SHIT!) thinks about this.
my comment over at marmalade:
as a person who has a BA in music...the first version is "interesting". It's not necessarily bad, but if a theory student handed that in for an assignment, I'd still probably fail them :) the 2nd arrangement, too-slow tempo notwithstanding, is actually pretty good. There are some suspended chords that are just beautiful. Sometimes you gotta think outside the musical box a little, you know?

